States

  • New Jersey
  • Pennsylvania
  • New York
  • Florida
  • Texas
  • California
  • Ohio
  • Illinois

Cities

  • Philadelphia, PA
  • New York, NY
  • Newark, NJ
  • Edison, NJ
  • Miami, FL
  • Chicago, IL
  • Houston, TX
  • Pittsburgh, PA

Trust

  • Ownership Transparency
  • NJ Accountability Report
  • PA Accountability Report
  • NY Accountability Report
  • FL Accountability Report
  • How we score
  • Suggest a feature

© 2026 Placet. No sponsored placements. No referral fees.

Terms

Rankings are based on CMS Provider Data and state public records. Placet receives no compensation from facilities. Data may be delayed. Verify current details directly with each facility before acting.

Placet
Care HubSearchFamily Guides
  1. Home
  2. Facilities
  3. NY
  4. Smithtown
  5. Best Rated

City Ranking Report

Best Rated Nursing Homes in Smithtown, NY

This list starts with the strongest CMS star performers in Smithtown, NY, then breaks ties with RN staffing depth and our Placet Trust Index.

Facilities

3

Beds

755

Avg CMS Stars

3.3

Top Trust Index

4.1/5

Best RatedNo PenaltiesTrach / VentMemory CareCardiac Rehab
1

Smithtown Center For Rehabilitation & Nursing Care

391 North Country Road, Smithtown
Trust Index 4.1/54-Star CMS0.6 RN hrs/day
Open facility
2

Brookside Multicare Nursing Center

7 Route 25a, Smithtown
Trust Index 4.1/53-Star CMS0.9 RN hrs/day$28K fines
Open facility
3

St Catherine Of Siena Nrsg And Rehab Care Center

52 Route 25a, Smithtown
Trust Index 4.1/53-Star CMS0.7 RN hrs/day$580K fines
Open facility